Disley teams and individuals have recorded a variety of honours since the club was reformed in 1987.

Senior Honours

  • 2015: Cheshire Cricket League Division C Runners-Up
  • 2015: Cheshire Cricket League 2ndXI Twenty20 Runners-Up
  • 2014: Cheshire Cricket League Division 2 Champions
  • 2013: Cheshire Cricket League Division 3 Champions
  • 2010: Cheshire Cricket League Fair Play Trophy Winners
  • 2009: Cheshire Cricket Alliance Division 1 Champions
  • 2009: Barclays Bank Knock-Out Trophy Champions
  • 2008: Barclays Bank Knock-Out Trophy Champions
  • 2008: Cheshire Cricket Alliance Division B Runners-Up
  • 2007: Cheshire Cricket Alliance Division 2 Champions
  • 2007: Barclays Bank Knock-Out Trophy Runners-Up
  • 2006: Barclays Bank Knock-Out Trophy Champions
  • 2005: Barclays Bank Knock-Out Trophy Runners-Up
  • 1990: Rhodes Cup Champions

Individual Honours

  • 2016: Cheshire Cricket League Division 1 Leading Bowler, Toby Carson
  • 2015: Cheshire District Junior Selection, Manusha Wettasinghe
  • 2007: Cheshire Cricket Alliance All-Rounder of the Year, Ross Arrowsmith
  • 2006: Cheshire Cricket Alliance Highest Individual Score, Andrew Clarke
  • 2006: Cheshire Cricket Alliance Leading Bowler, Simon Hare
  • 2004: Cheshire Junior Selection, James Williamson
  • 1996: Derbyshire Junior Selection, Tim Baker

A record of all senior competitive centuries and 7+ wicket hauls can be found on the honours board located in the bar area of the Disley Amalgamated Sports Club.